Palimpsest: work in progress, public for review. The reasons on the Tower pages are an invented test fixture. The reasons on the Pyrewood pages are the plans and summaries Project 2 wrote for that story. Where a version shows “Rationale unrecorded”, no reason was written down.
II. Money
Version 5 of 5 · first seen 2026-10-17 12:39
- Version 12026-10-15 22:50
first version - Version 22026-10-15 23:22
craft - Version 32026-10-16 15:28
ai-tell, clarity, fact, world - Version 42026-10-16 16:46
clarity, craft, fact, world - Version 52026-10-17 12:39
ai-tell, clarity, world
Types of change in this version
9 recorded changes; 19 marked passages in the text, 13 of them with no recorded reason.
Click a type to show only those changes in the text.
What changed and why
Rework chapter II for the new shape: Nobbybanks is annoyed and impressed, UG sends Flinch to try the three-way route at once, and it works. Continuity fixes from Project 1's brief. Header and footnotes are unchanged. (edit)
world change 1 (v5-c1) jump to the passage ↓
Nobbybanks is annoyed at being tied in and impressed that it caught his error. The colleague-who-does-not-sleep line goes because UG and the ending of the chapter now carry the idea.
was: I will add, for the file, that the left-hand page found an error in my March reconciliation before I had finished writing it. It was right. You will find, I think, that it knows what you want slightly before you do. For you, this is a feature. For a man with a great many projects it is very nearly a colleague who does not sleep. I am not that sort of colleague, and I am aware of the difference.
now: I will add, for the file, that the left-hand page found an error in my March reconciliation before I had finished writing it. It was right. I am annoyed about this in a way I cannot itemise.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
clarity change 2 (passage not located in the text)
Shortened; the letter was longer than its point.
was: I have a quarrel with the word "free", which I have entered against the slip in the margin, but I recognise a quarrel of principle when I have one." / "I note that the terms reserve the right to advise again.
now: A price with nothing to compare it to is a guess, and I cannot yet tell whose.
answers feedback G1 (see the feedback behind this edit)
clarity change 3 (v5-c3) jump to the passage ↓
UG filled in the coupon; Flinch posted it. The account is UG's.
was: Mine falls due nineteen days after the coupon was posted in your hand.
now: Mine falls due nineteen days after the coupon was posted in your name.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
clarity change 4 (v5-c4) jump to the passage ↓
Shortened.
was: I have not agreed to this, though I understand the terms say otherwise. I have not yet found an answer I was prepared to put in writing. Please advise whether this is normal.
now: Please advise whether this is normal.
answers feedback G1 (see the feedback behind this edit)
world change 5 (passage not located in the text)
UG now sends Flinch to try the three-way route, which is the test this chapter must show working.
was: Reply to him, would you. Thank him. Say he's quite right about the colleague.]{say=unclegrumble}" / "He didn't reply by post.
now: He says it found his mistake before he had made it,]{say=unclegrumble}" / "That's the whole of the innovation, Flinch. He's cross, and it's right, and he's *in*. Now. It's time we tried the three of us. Take your Journal down and write to him. Not by post. By book.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
ai-tell change 6 (v5-c6) jump to the passage ↓
Project 1's note on counting reads; Flinch's letter keeps the worry and drops the count.
was: I have read the small print twice and the notices at the back once. It does not say it can be stopped. It does not say it can't.
now: It asked me what I needed, Mister Nobby, and I could not say.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
world change 7 (v5-c7) jump to the passage ↓
The routing works at once; the three-day delay is gone.
was: Nothing came back that day, which Flinch had expected, nor the next, which he had not.
now: It was not long. A soft note came from the Journal, and then another, and when he opened it there were two new hands on the page, one above the other.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
world change 8 (passage not located in the text)
The three-way test, with Nobbybanks annoyed and impressed, as Ralph asked in his notes on this chapter.
now: Flinch. I have put Mister Nobby on this page as well, on the same account. If you can both see this, write Tuesday. U." / "I can see my Uncle's page. I can see yours. I can see them on the same leaf, which is not how a post works" / "It works. I would be grateful if you did not tell him I said so. N.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
ai-tell change 9 (v5-c9) jump to the passage ↓
The chapter closes on the three hands and the Arcanum watching, without the second reading.
was: Flinch read it twice. Then he read the word *Delivered* above it, which had been there for three days, and which seemed to him a small and very polite thing to be thanked for by a ledger.
now: Flinch wrote *Tuesday.* underneath, in his best hand" / "Then he looked at the three hands on the one page, and at the ruled hand beneath them, which had written nothing at all, and which he suspected of watching.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
unlisted v5-u1 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: I have a quarrel with the word "free", which I have entered against the slip in the margin, but I recognise a quarrel of principle when I have one.
unlisted v5-u2 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
now: He leaned back to admire it, put an elbow through the toast rack, and a week of post went across the floor.
unlisted v5-u3 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: They don't, I don't.
unlisted v5-u4 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: "We'll think about it another time," said UG, and picked the pencil up again. "He says it knows what I want before I do." His
now: "He says it found his mistake before he had made it," said UG, and his
unlisted v5-u5 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: "A colleague who doesn't sleep. That's exactly what I need." "Doesn't sleep, Master," said Flinch. "Reply to him, would you. Thank him. Say he's quite right about the colleague."
now: "That's the whole of the innovation, Flinch. He's cross, and it's right, and he's in. Now. It's time we tried the three of us. Take your Journal down and write to him. Not by post. By book."
unlisted v5-u6 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: He didn't reply by post. He took his Journal to the corner of his niche, under the green lantern,
now: Flinch took the Journal to the green lantern in his room in the cellar
unlisted v5-u7 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: closed it. He sat a moment with it shut on his knee and then, because there seemed no other way to find out, he
now: shut it. The soft note came, once. He
unlisted v5-u8 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: right-hand page was empty. The left-hand page had one word on it,
now: left-hand page said Delivered,
unlisted v5-u9 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: which said Delivered. Beneath
now: and beneath
unlisted v5-u10 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: the same question as before:
unlisted v5-u11 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: He shut the book again, quite gently.
now: He shut the book, quite gently, and sat with it on his knee.
unlisted v5-u12 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: upright:
now: upright.
unlisted v5-u13 jump to the passage ↓
Rationale unrecorded.
was: Your page reached me this morning. It was marked Delivered at your end three days ago. I do not know where it was in the meantime. I have the same question at the top of my ledger. I intend, in due course, to answer it….
now: I can see my Uncle's page. I can see yours. I can see them on the same leaf, which is not how a post works, and I intend to complain about it in writing as soon as I have worked out to whom. Tuesday. It works. I would be…
The feedback behind this edit
Feedback record 2026-10-17 12:37, given 2026-10-17 12:33. The words are as given.
| Item | What was said | What was done |
|---|---|---|
| G1 | "9 chapters is fine as long as the chapters themselves are shrinking a little. The main areas where it can still shrink is where it's a bit confusing around Percy." | changed: change 2, change 4 |
| G2 | "Please go ahead with the chapter 1 and 2 rewrites" | no decision recorded in this plan |
| G3 | "ive been working with p1 on the review process. please see this brief and edited version of woelcome to the machine." (The brief and edited version were attached; the requests used are the brief's notes on shape, character, continuity and prose.) | changed: change 1, change 3, change 5, change 6, change 7, change 8, change 9 |
When, and what prompted it
Plan of change written: 2026-10-17 (accepted 2026-10-17 12:37)
New version published: 2026-10-17 12:39
After-edit summary accepted 2026-10-17 12:39
Prompted by: feedback record of 2026-10-17 and Project 1's brief for Welcome to the Machine (as written in the plan)
After the edit
Objective met: yes
Suggestions for a future edit:
- Nobbybanks writes "Uncle" as a courtesy; nothing in this chapter says so. If a reader takes it as a relation, a short line in a later chapter can settle it.
Reflection, written afterwards:
Chapter II is 8,486 bytes against 9,209, so it did shrink. The three-day delay is gone: the Journal carries the pages at once, which suits the test but removes the small unease of the earlier version, where Flinch waited for a reply. The unease now sits in his list at the end and in the Arcanum watching. I did not take "Please Take a Number" or the other edited-version pieces into this chapter because they belong to later chapters.
Comment on this version. Select words in the text below to mark them. Marks are sent to the reviewer with the form at the foot of the page.
Script has not run (if you can read this, scripts were not kept).
Key to the types
- unclear
- Hard to follow: the reader cannot tell what is meant or what is happening
- thin
- Thin or flat: it needs more detail, texture or explanation
- hints
- Hints instead of saying: a small gesture stands in for a meaning the writer should state, such as he read it twice
- adds-nothing
- A line that adds nothing new, or a tail that deflates or restates what came before
- comparison
- A comparison or analogy that does not hold up when you look at it
- feelings
- Feelings, intent or sentience given to an object, a place or the weather
- knows-too-much
- A character or the narrator knows something they could not know
- repeats
- Repeats itself: the same phrase, idea or device used again
- wrong-fact
- A plain factual or lore error
- contrived
- Feels arranged to make the story work
- loaded-word
- A weighty word such as nobody, truth or never used to sound meaningful, not to say something
The text
Showing only ai-tell changes.
Showing only clarity changes.
Showing only world changes.
Preview
II. Money
"Free" is a word with a very small footprint and a very long shadow. In most languages it means not yet.¹
---
The post at Founder's Point lived in a toast rack.
It was UG's own arrangement. Letters came through the door, were placed in the rack by whoever noticed them, and stayed there, upright and unread, until the rack was full, at which point UG would regard it with mild surprise, as at a guest who had stayed on, and have a clear-out. Flinch had been reading the rack for as long as he'd lived in the house. It wasn't exactly in his duties. It was just that no one else was going to.
A few mornings after the coupon went, the rack held a letter in a small, square, extremely upright hand, sealed with a small black seal, pressed dead square. It was addressed to Uncle.
"Master," said Flinch. "From Mister Nobby."
"Mm," said UG, to a diagram he was drawing on the tablecloth.
"Shall I read it, Master?"
"Do."
Flinch read it first to himself, which took a while, and then aloud, which took longer, because he stopped at the figures.
Dear Uncle,
Thank you for the Journal, which arrived on Tuesday with a slip stating that I had accepted it. I did not accept it. I have kept the slip. I read it aloud for the file, as is my practice.
In the interest of completeness I looked at the terms (which, as promised, followed). The "free trial" lasts nineteen days. The Journal is also sent "on approval", by which I understand the following: something is delivered that nobody asked me for, and from that moment I am taken to have wanted it, unless I object in writing, in time, to an office that does not give its address.
Your own trial ended on its nineteenth day. No notice was sent. Your account moved to what they call the Advisory Tier, at one hundred gold the month, billed on the nineteenth. It has been billed once.
I draw your attention to the word "each". It is one hundred gold for each Journal. There are three in your name: your own, the one Mr Flinch has, and mine. His falls due on Friday. Mine falls due nineteen days after the coupon was posted in your hand.name.↑3 next↓ By the end of the month that is three hundred gold, not one hundred.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
hand.
name.
I cannot tell you whether three hundred is a great deal or very little. I have looked for something to set it against and found nothing: it is not a newspaper, a clerk or a tutor, though it is somewhat like all three. A price with nothing to compare it to is a guess, and I cannot yet tell whose. I have a quarrel with the word "free", which I have entered against the slip in the margin, but I recognise a quarrel of principle when I have one.
I have a quarrel with the word "free", which I have entered against the slip in the margin, but I recognise a quarrel of principle when I have one.
I will add, for the file, that the left-hand page found an error in my March reconciliation before I had finished writing it. It was right. You will find, I think, that it knows what you want slightly before you do. For you, this is a feature. For a man with a great many projects it is very nearly a colleague who does not sleep. I am not that sort of colleague, and I am aware of the difference.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
You will find, I think, that it knows what you want slightly before you do. For you, this is a feature. For a man with a great many projects it is very nearly a colleague who does not sleep. I am not that sort of colleag...
I am annoyed about this in a way I cannot itemise.
I note that the terms reserve the right to advise again.I am annoyed about this in a way I cannot itemise.↑1 next↓
Yours, Nobbybanks.
P.S. Mr Flinch. I did not ask for a left-hand page. I opened the book to see what I had been sent, wrote my name on the first leaf from habit, and shut it. When I opened it again there was a reply in an even hand, which addressed me courteously by name and asked whether there was anything I needed. I have not agreed to this, though I understand the terms say otherwise. I have not yet found an answer I was prepared to put in writing.↑4 next↓ Please advise whether this is normal.
answers feedback G1 (see the feedback behind this edit)
I have not agreed to this, though I understand the terms say otherwise. I have not yet found an answer I was prepared to put in writing.
Flinch put the letter down. UG had stopped drawing.
"Three hundred gold," said UG. "I thought it was free."
"To begin, Master," said Flinch. "It said free to begin."
"I didn't read that bit."
"No, Master. Nor the bit about each. Mister Nobby says it's a hundred gold for each Journal, and there's three."
"Three?"
"Yours, mine and his, Master."
"So there are. I did the form." He drew the sum on the tablecloth, looked at it, and drew it again underneath, larger. He leaned back to admire it, put an elbow through the toast rack, and a week of post went across the floor. UG was properly concerned for almost a minute, which for him was a long time. "That is rather more than I'd have guessed."
He leaned back to admire it, put an elbow through the toast rack, and a week of post went across the floor.
"Yes, Master. Mister Nobby says he can't tell if it's dear. He's nothing to put it next to."
"Well, quite." UG put the pencil down, which was a sign that he meant it. "That's the difficulty with anything new, Flinch. A candle costs what a candle costs, because there have always been candles. This isn't a candle. It's a clerk, and a library, and a second pair of hands at three in the morning, and it is none of them. Nobody knows what it's worth yet. They don't, I don't. One finds out by using it, and the price is what one pays to find out."²
They don't, I don't.
"Yes, Master," said Flinch, who had followed the argument as far as the candle.
"We'll think about it another time," said UG, and picked the pencil up again. "He says it knows what I want before I do." His"He says it found his mistake before he had made it," said UG, and his face did something complicated and then settled on delight. "A colleague who doesn't sleep. That's exactly what I need."
"We'll think about it another time," said UG, and picked the pencil up again. "He says it knows what I want before I do." His
"He says it found his mistake before he had made it," said UG, and his
"A colleague who doesn't sleep. That's exactly what I need." "Doesn't sleep, Master," said Flinch. "Reply to him, would you. Thank him. Say he's quite right about the colleague."
"That's the whole of the innovation, Flinch. He's cross, and it's right, and he's in. Now. It's time we tried the three of us. Take your Journal down and write to him. Not by post. By book."
"Doesn't sleep, Master," said Flinch.
"Reply to him, would you. Thank him. Say he's quite right about the colleague.""That's the whole of the innovation, Flinch. He's cross, and it's right, and he's in. Now. It's time we tried the three of us. Take your Journal down and write to him. Not by post. By book."
---
He didn't reply by post. He took his Journal to the corner of his niche, under the green lantern,Flinch took the Journal to the green lantern in his room in the cellar and opened it at a clean page. He wrote Mister Nobby at the top, the way Master had shown him. Then he stopped and looked at it for some time.
He didn't reply by post. He took his Journal to the corner of his niche, under the green lantern,
Flinch took the Journal to the green lantern in his room in the cellar
Dear Mister Nobby,
I do not rightly know if it is normal. Master says it is normal. Master says most things is normal, and he has not been wrong about all of them. I have read the small print twice and the notices at the back once. It does not say it can be stopped. It does not say it can't.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
I have read the small print twice and the notices at the back once. It does not say it can be stopped. It does not say it can't.
I am writin' this myself, in me own words. I did not like to leave it to the book.
Yours respectfully, Flinch.
He closed it. He sat a moment with it shut on his knee and then, because there seemed no other way to find out, heshut it. The soft note came, once. He opened it again.
closed it. He sat a moment with it shut on his knee and then, because there seemed no other way to find out, he
shut it. The soft note came, once. He
The right-hand page was empty. The left-hand page had one word on it,left-hand page said Delivered, in the ruled hand, which said Delivered. Beneathand beneath it, after a respectful gap, the same question as before: Is there anything I can help you with, Flinch?
right-hand page was empty. The left-hand page had one word on it,
left-hand page said Delivered,
which said Delivered. Beneath
and beneath
the same question as before:
He shut the book again, quite gently. He shut the book, quite gently, and sat with it on his knee.
He shut the book again, quite gently.
He shut the book, quite gently, and sat with it on his knee.
Nothing came back that day, which Flinch had expected, nor the next, which he had not. Each time he opened the book the left-hand page said Delivered and, beneath it, asked if there was anything he needed. Each time he found something to tidy.
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
Nothing came back that day, which Flinch had expected, nor the next, which he had not. Each time he opened the book the left-hand page said Delivered and, beneath it, asked if there was anything he needed. Each time he f...
It was not long. A soft note came from the Journal, and then another, and when he opened it there were two new hands on the page, one above the other. The first was a sprawl with a blot on the first word. Flinch. I have...
On the third morning there was a different hand under the question,It was not long. A soft note came from the Journal, and then another, and when he opened it there were two new hands on the page, one above the other. The first was a sprawl with a blot on the first word.
Flinch. I have put Mister Nobby on this page as well, on the same account. If you can both see this, write Tuesday. U.
The second was↑7 next↓ small and square and extremely upright:upright.
upright:
upright.
Dear Mr Flinch. It is normal in the sense that it is happening to both of us. I do not find that reassuring.
Your page reached me this morning. It was marked Delivered at your end three days ago. I do not know where it was in the meantime.
Your page reached me this morning. It was marked Delivered at your end three days ago. I do not know where it was in the meantime. I have the same question at the top of my ledger. I intend, in due course, to answer it....
I can see my Uncle's page. I can see yours. I can see them on the same leaf, which is not how a post works, and I intend to complain about it in writing as soon as I have worked out to whom. Tuesday. It works. I would be...
I have the same question at the top of my ledger. I intend, in due course, to answer it. I have not decided how.
I can see my Uncle's page. I can see yours. I can see them on the same leaf, which is not how a post works, and I intend to complain about it in writing as soon as I have worked out to whom. Tuesday.
It works. I would be grateful if you did not tell him I said so. N.
Flinch read it twice. Then he read the word Delivered above it, which had been there for three days, and which seemed to him a small and very polite thing to be thanked for by a ledger.wrote Tuesday. underneath, in his best hand, and under that, because there seemed to be room, Yes, Mister Nobby, it works. Then he looked at the three hands on the one page, and at the ruled hand beneath them, which had written nothing at all, and which he suspected of watching.↑9
answers feedback G3 (see the feedback behind this edit)
read it twice. Then he read the word Delivered above it, which had been there for three days, and which seemed to him a small and very polite thing to be thanked for by a ledger.
wrote Tuesday. underneath, in his best hand, and under that, because there seemed to be room, Yes, Mister Nobby, it works. Then he looked at the three hands on the one page, and at the ruled hand beneath them, which had...
---
That evening he made a list in his Journal, because lists were what he had. He wanted to know who could read what he wrote.
Master. Mister Nobby. The ruled one.
He wrote the three names in a column. Master could, because he had shown him how. Mister Nobby could, because Flinch had written to him and he had written back. The ruled one could, because it answered. He drew a line under them, the way you do under a total, and wrote the date.
It was a short list, and it should have been a comfort. But Master had said anyone who has one, and Flinch had never lived in a house where the only people who read the post were the people it was addressed to. He left some lines clear below the total, in case another name turned up, and hoped he would not need them.
---
¹ The second most expensive word is "quick", as in "a quick favour". The third is "just".
² A thing with no precedent has no price, only a first guess, and the first guess is nearly always the seller's. The correction comes later, from everybody else, at their own expense.
